Managed Cloud or Traditional IT Services: Pros and Cons
IT Services for small and midsize businesses have evolved over the years. The technologies and IT systems we use are more capable and complex. We face new and ongoing challenges related to collaboration and security. Our IT is a critical component of our business infrastructure.
The management and support of our information technology and services need a more sophisticated approach to match our business and technology needs. Traditional IT services have their Pros and Cons. Managed Cloud Services offer new opportunities, especially for smaller businesses.
Traditional IT Services
Traditional IT services fall into two main categories: Break-Fix and Managed Services.
Break-Fix
As the name implies Break-Fix is a reactive service. When you have a question or problem, you call for assistance. You pay an hourly or per-incident rate or use a bank of prepaid hours.
Pros
- Break-Fix is often affordable, particularly if your IT systems are relatively new and stable. If you have few or occasional problems, you only pay for the services you need.
Cons
- Break-Fix is reactive. When something goes wrong, your business is likely disrupted until your IT resource can respond, diagnose, and correct the issue.
- Your costs are unpredictable.
- A problem may be a quick-fix or may require significant time to research and resolve.
- Most break-fix firms charge more per hour or per incident for emergency and off-hours services.
- You are more likely to have problems. You are not paying your IT firm to monitor your systems and services. You are not likely to identify issues before they become problems that disrupt your business.
- Impact of disruptions. Beyond the cost of the fix, disruptive ITproblems impact your business in other ways.
- You may not be able to respond to customers or meet client expectations
- Your cashflow can suffer if you are unable to invoice or process receivables
- Your reputation may suffer if you are seen as unreliable
- Conflicting Interests. While no reputable IT firm wants their clients to have problems, break-fix IT firms rely on service and support calls for their revenue.
Managed Services
Managed Services provide a wide range of IT administration, management, and support services for a set monthly fee. Often positioned as a full or partial outsourcing of your IT services, Managed Services provide an active approach to IT services. Managed Service Providers (MSPs) actively monitor and manage your environment to prevent problems that can disrupt your business.
Pros
- Managed Services are proactive. MSPs will focus on best-practice configuration, administration, and security to prevent and mitigate problems.
- Your costs are predictable. Most MSPs will charge a fixed monthly fee for the set of services they provide. MSPs typically base fees on the number of devices, services, and systems/applications they manage and support.
- You are less likely to have problems. Good MSPs will identify and address issues before they become disruptive problems.
- Your MSP is aligned with your interests. MSPs do better when their clients have fewer problems that require intervention. The business model for MSPs relies on efficiencies and economies of scale. Fixing problems is more costly than preventing them, so good MSPs focus on prevention.
Cons
- Costs. Managed Services appear to cost more than break-fix services.
- Monthly fees can range from $150 to over $250 per user per month. While this is a budgetary issue for many, and for small businesses in particular, the benefits of well-managed IT services will outweigh the costs.
- Many MSPs require clients to migrate to a standard set of systems and components. Replacing network and systems infrastructure can add significant costs to the onboarding process.
- Access. To obtain their economies of scale, most MSPs focus on businesses with 20 or more employees. Very small businesses (VSBs) – those with fewer than 20 people, solopreneurs, and solo practitioners often struggle to access MSPs and their services.
Managed Cloud Services
Managed Cloud Services are similar to Managed Services, but focus on cloud-based services to better meet the needs of small and midsize businesses. While Managed Services focus on your IT “things” – computers, servers, networks, etc., Managed Cloud Services focus on your people – the tools they need to succeed in their roles.
While Managed Cloud Service Providers (MCSPs) will still monitor, manage, and support your technology infrastructure, computers, and on-site systems, our focus is moving as much as possible to the cloud. Reducing on-premise systems dramatically reduces the resources we need to support your business, allowing us to meet your IT needs more cost-effectively.
Pros
- Your costs are lower. Leveraging cloud services simplifies your IT environment and reduces the resources needed to support your business. Monthly charges for Managed Cloud Services often run 30% or more below traditional managed services.
- Your costs are predictable. You will pay a fixed monthly fee for Managed Cloud Services based on the scope of services provided.
- You have fewer problems and disruptions. Leveraging cloud-based solutions reduces the number of things that can have problems. Providing business resiliency and continuity with cloud solutions is more cost-effective.
- Better access to services. MCSPs leverage cloud solutions to achieve economies of scale that enable affordable services for SMBs, VSBs, and sole practitioners.
- Your MCSP is aligned with your interests. MCSPs do better when you do better.
Cons
- Reliance on vendors. Your MSCP cannot fix a Microsoft 365 outage or issue. With some cloud solutions, your alternatives may be limited. Even so, cloud outages are typically shorter in duration than local IT issues and are not bound by the availability of parts or technicians for on-site work.
How Does Cumulus Global Help?
At Cumulus Global, our priority is ensuring that you have productive, secure, and affordable Managed Cloud Services, Cloud Forward IT Service and Support, and Security CPR™ Managed Security services. We focus on how your IT services can best help your business thrive and grow without overspending.
Schedule a meeting with a Cloud Advisor to discuss your challenges, needs, and priorities. We will help you assess, plan, and execute the right IT services for your business and your budget.
About the Author
Allen Falcon is the co-founder and CEO of Cumulus Global. Allen co-founded Cumulus Global in 2006 to offer small businesses enterprise-grade email security and compliance using emerging cloud solutions. He has led the company’s growth into a managed cloud service provider with over 1,000 customers throughout North America.